Managing Operational Performance: KPIs, Plans and Performance Reviews
A premium course for managers who run a unit, site, service or function: turning priorities into an operating plan, choosing a small set of leading and lagging KPIs, using a balanced scorecard, avoiding target gaming and running a monthly performance review that ends in actions. It uses ISO 9001 and ISO 22400-2, Kaplan and Norton’s balanced scorecard, and the documented Wells Fargo and Mid Staffordshire cases. Not an accredited qualification.
What you will learn
- Translate organisational priorities into an operating plan with owners and dates.
- Select and define a small set of leading and lagging KPIs.
- Build a balanced scorecard covering customers, processes, people and finance.
- Recognise and prevent target gaming and its harms.
- Run a monthly performance review that ends in owned actions.
Modules
- From priorities to an operating plan
- Choosing the right KPIs
- A balanced scorecard
- Targets, gaming and unintended harm
- The monthly performance review
Course facts
- Estimated study time
- about 1.5 hours
- Final assessment
- 10 questions · Pass mark 80%
- Available in
- English, Français, العربية
- Price
- Free. Optional verifiable certificate: $12
- Last updated
- Published by
- AMAADOR ACADEMY
Who this course is for
Operations, site, service, quality and department managers, and supervisors preparing for a management role.
Prerequisites
No formal prerequisite. Basic spreadsheet skills help.
Course content
1. From priorities to an operating plan
Operational managers sit between strategy and daily work. Senior leaders set a handful of priorities; the manager’s job is to turn them into an operating plan for the unit: a few objectives with measures and dates, the main actions, who owns each, and the resources needed. ISO 9001 expresses the same idea for quality objectives: they should be measurable, consistent with policy, monitored, communicated and planned with what will be done, by whom, with what resources, by when and how results will be evaluated.
Start with demand and capacity. How much work is coming (orders, patients, tickets, projects), when are the peaks, and how much can the team deliver with current people and equipment? Many failed plans are wish-lists that ignore capacity. Write down the assumptions — volumes, staffing, budget — so that when they change you know which parts of the plan to revisit.
Keep the plan short enough to use. One page per unit is often enough: three to five objectives, each with an owner, a measure and quarterly milestones. Share it with the team and connect each person’s goals to it. If people cannot say how their work links to the plan, the plan is not doing its job.
Key point: One page: a few measurable objectives, owners, milestones and the capacity assumptions behind them.
2. Choosing the right KPIs
A key performance indicator is a measure that tells you whether an objective is being met. Lagging indicators report results after the fact: output, defects, cost per unit, customer complaints, lost-time injuries. Leading indicators show the conditions that drive those results: planned maintenance completed, training done, backlog age, first-time-right rate. A useful dashboard pairs each important lagging result with one or two leading measures that you can act on this week.
Fewer is better. A manager who tracks forty indicators manages none of them. Pick the handful that matter for your objectives, and write a definition for each: the formula, the data source, the frequency, the owner and the target. ISO 22400-2 does this for manufacturing operations, defining indicators such as overall equipment effectiveness (OEE), throughput and scrap ratio with their formulas, so that two plants calculate them the same way.
Test each KPI before you adopt it. Can the team influence it? Is the data reliable and cheap to collect? Would improving it really improve the objective, or could it be improved in ways that hurt something else? John Doerr’s objectives and key results (OKR) approach adds a useful discipline: an objective says what you want, and two to four key results say how you will know you got there.
Key point: Pair each lagging result with a leading measure, and write a definition before you report a number.
3. A balanced scorecard
In 1992 Robert Kaplan and David Norton argued in the Harvard Business Review that financial measures alone describe the past and can encourage short-term decisions. Their balanced scorecard adds three other perspectives: the customer (how do customers see us?), internal business processes (what must we excel at?), and innovation and learning, later called learning and growth (can we continue to improve and create value?).
For an operational manager the idea scales down well. Choose two or three measures in each perspective: customer satisfaction or on-time delivery; process quality, cycle time or safety; people measures such as training completed, absence or staff turnover; and cost against budget. The value is in the balance: a unit that hits its cost target by cutting maintenance or training will show warning signs in the other perspectives before the damage reaches the financial results.
Show trends, not single months. A one-page scorecard with six to twelve months of data, a target line and a simple red, amber, green status lets a review focus on what is changing. The Balanced Scorecard Institute and Kaplan and Norton’s later work stress linking measures to strategy through cause-and-effect: better training leads to fewer errors, which leads to faster delivery and happier customers, which leads to better financial results.
Key point: Balance customer, process, people and financial measures, and show 6–12 months of trend.
4. Targets, gaming and unintended harm
Targets focus effort, but pressure on a single number invites people to hit the number rather than the purpose behind it. The economist Charles Goodhart’s observation is often paraphrased as “when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure”. Gaming takes predictable forms: reclassifying incidents, closing tickets before the problem is solved, shifting costs between periods, or meeting a waiting-time target by delaying the start of the clock.
Two public cases show the scale of harm. In 2016 the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau fined Wells Fargo $100 million after finding that employees, under sales targets and incentive pressure, had opened about 1.5 million deposit accounts and submitted applications for about 565,000 credit cards that customers may not have authorised. In England, the 2013 Francis Report into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust described a culture that focused on targets and finances at the expense of patient care, with appalling suffering in some wards.
Managers can reduce the risk. Use a balanced set of measures so that gains in one area at another’s expense become visible. Check data quality and audit a sample of records. Watch for results that look too good. Avoid tying large personal rewards to a single number. Above all, ask the team how the target could be gamed and what it might make people neglect — and listen to the answers.
Key point: Any single target can be gamed: balance measures, check data and ask what the target might make people neglect.
Case study: Wells Fargo sales targets (United States, 2016). The CFPB found that employees had opened deposit and credit-card accounts without customers’ knowledge to meet sales goals and earn incentives. The bank was fined $100 million by the CFPB, alongside other regulators’ penalties. The lesson for managers: aggressive targets without balancing measures and control checks can turn ordinary staff into rule-breakers.
5. The monthly performance review
A monthly performance review is the Plan–Do–Check–Act cycle in meeting form. Send the scorecard two days before, so the meeting discusses rather than reads. Spend most of the time on the few measures that are off track or moving the wrong way, not on reciting green ones. ISO 9001’s requirements for monitoring, analysis and management review follow the same logic: data should lead to decisions on improvement, resources and changes.
For each issue ask three questions. What happened, compared with target and trend? What is the likely cause, and what evidence supports it? What will we do, who owns it and by when? Distinguish normal variation from a real change: one bad week in an otherwise stable series may need watching, not a new initiative. Simple tools — a run chart, a Pareto of causes, a five-whys conversation — are usually enough at this level.
End every review with a short action list, and open the next review by checking it. Actions that roll over month after month are a sign of overload or unclear ownership; deal with that directly. Record decisions briefly. Over a year, the action log becomes the best evidence of how the unit is managed — useful for audits, for your own manager and for the next person in your role.
Key point: Pre-read the scorecard, spend the time on off-track measures, and end with owned actions you check next month.
The full lesson, case studies, scenarios and templates continue in the interactive course on this page.
Sources and references
- ISO 9001:2015 Quality management systems — Requirements (catalogue)
- ISO 22400-2 Key performance indicators for manufacturing operations management (catalogue)
- Kaplan & Norton (1992) The Balanced Scorecard — Measures That Drive Performance
- Balanced Scorecard Institute — basics and resources
- CFPB fines Wells Fargo $100 million for secretly opening unauthorized accounts (2016)
- Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry (Francis, 2013)
Management education only, not an accredited qualification. ISO content is paraphrased from public catalogue pages without reproducing paid text; check the ISO catalogue for current editions. Case facts are taken from the public reports cited.